In this much belated post, I will draw from my sermon series in September on church covenants. I am deeply indebted to Charles W. Deweese and his work on Baptist church covenants entitled Baptist Church Covenants and credit that work as the principal source of the historical evidence I present on the issue. The question that I pose in this post is, “Are church covenants Baptistic?” Can we find a strong foundation in Baptist history for the use of church covenants in Baptist churches? By no means do I present these thoughts as an exhaustive work on the subject; rather, I intend to highlight some examples and facts from Deweese’s work pertaining to the question.
Deweese mentions that one sees the arrival of church covenants in early English Baptist churches in the 1600’s. These covenants contained statements generally focusing on four areas of church life. They addressed church fellowship, referring to the individual’s commitment to God and to other believers in the church. Secondly, they mentioned church discipline, describing the process of discipline and indicating a willingness among church members to submit to such discipline. Early English Baptist covenants emphasized the need for public worship and private devotion. They asserted that church members should exercise pastoral care and a pastoral attitude towards all other members. These covenants were an essential part of early English Baptist church life and provided a foundation for covenants that would appear in early American Baptist churches.
Church covenants play an important role in early American Baptist life. Isaac Backus produced a covenant that as used by numerous Baptist churches in colonial New England. Welsh Neck Baptist Church, developed a covenant that was used by numerous other churches in the Pee Dee area of South Carolina (where our church Lakeview Baptist is located). In 1774, the Charleston Baptist Association defined a church as “a company of saints, incorporated by special covenant into one distinct body. . ..” All of these examples show an emphasis on church covenants that was evident in early Baptist churches in America.
In its history, the Southern Baptist Convention has also placed emphasis on the importance of church covenants. In 1927, the SBC’s Commission on the Cooperative Program promoted Church Covenant Month. During this month, the Commission encouraged pastors to preach on the church covenant and for congregations to read their covenants aloud during worship. In its article on the church, The Baptist Faith & Message states, “A New Testament church of the Lord Jesus Christ is an autonomous local congregation of baptized believers, associated by covenant in faith and fellowship of the gospel….” It is widely known among Southern Baptists that The Baptist Hymnal (1956) had a copy of J. Newton Brown’s covenant glued inside the front cover. The Sunday School Board and currently Lifeway currently offer for purchase covenant cards that can be signed by members joining a church. These examples are but a few pieces of evidence that show the place that church covenants have had in Southern Baptist life.
So, back to my original question, “Are church covenants Baptistic?” Baptist history responds with a resounding, “Yes!”